Digging Deeper: What If God Withholds?
Sellers Hickman
on
October 22, 2026

9 Or which one of you, if his son asks him for bread, will give him a stone? 10 Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a serpent? 11 If you then, who are evil, know how to give good gifts to your children, how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things to those who ask him!
Matthew 7:9-11 (ESV)
WHAT IF GOD WITHHOLDS?
We’ve spent the last few days talking about prayer, and if you’ve been following along, you may be asking… What if God doesn’t answer my prayer? That’s a much harder question. It’s easy to talk about prayer when the answer is yes. We love the stories where someone prays for something and God comes through in an incredible way. We love hearing about the impossible situation that suddenly changed, the healing that nobody expected, or the door that opened at exactly the right time. Those stories remind us that God hears our prayers and that He is capable of doing far more than we could imagine. But what about when you pray and nothing changes? What about when you ask God to bring about good health and He doesn’t? What about when you pray for a relationship to work out and it ends? What about when you ask God to open a door and it stays firmly shut? What about when you pray for years for something and the answer seems to be silence?
Our passage from last Sunday gives us such hope. Matthew 7:9–11 gives us one of the most comforting pictures of God in the entire Bible. Jesus says, “Which one of you, if his son asks him for bread, will give him a stone? Or if he asks for a fish, will give him a serpent?” Jesus is making a simple point: good parents want good things for their children. If we, as imperfect people, know how to give good gifts to our children, “how much more will your Father who is in heaven give good things to those who ask him!” I love that Jesus calls God our Father. He doesn’t describe Him as a distant God who reluctantly listens to our requests. He describes a Father who knows us, loves us, and wants to give good things to His children. But there is something important we have to remember. God being good does not mean God will give us everything we ask for.
As a parent, there will be plenty of things my daughters ask me for that I will say no to. That doesn’t mean I don’t love them. In fact, sometimes the reason I say no is because I love them. A child may not understand why the answer is no because they can only see what they want in that moment. A parent has a different perspective. God has a completely different perspective than we do. There are things I have prayed for that I desperately wanted God to say yes to. There are things I have prayed about where I was convinced I knew exactly what God needed to do. But looking back, I can also see moments when what I thought was a good thing wasn’t actually the best thing for me. That doesn’t make the “no” easy. Sometimes we use phrases like “God has something better” so casually that we forget how painful it can be to actually live through unanswered prayer. There are moments when you don’t want a lesson. You don’t want character development. You don’t want to hear that God has a different plan. You just want the thing you prayed for.
Here is a truth that maybe you need to hear today. God can handle your honesty! You don’t have to pretend that a “no” doesn’t hurt. You don’t have to convince yourself that you never wanted what you prayed for. You can bring your disappointment to God because He is not threatened by your questions, your frustration, or even your grief. Jesus Himself modeled this in the Garden of Gethsemane. He prayed that the cup of suffering would be taken from Him, but ultimately surrendered Himself to the Father’s will. The prayer wasn’t wrong because He asked for something that didn’t happen. The prayer was an honest expression of what He desired, followed by a willingness to trust the Father. That may be one of the hardest parts of prayer: when we continue to trust God when His answer is not the one we wanted.
Sometimes the answer is yes. Sometimes the answer is no. Sometimes the answer is not yet. And sometimes we may never fully understand the answer this side of eternity. But Matthew 7 reminds us that whatever the answer is, we can trust the heart of the One giving it. Jesus doesn’t say, “Your Father in heaven will give you everything you ask for.” He says your Father will give good things to those who ask Him. That means our confidence in prayer ultimately cannot rest in getting what we want. It must rest in knowing who we are asking. If my confidence in God is dependent on Him giving me the answer I want, then I will eventually find myself disappointed with Him. But if my confidence is rooted in who He is, then even when I don’t understand His answer, I can still trust Him.
Maybe that is where you are today. You have prayed the same prayer over and over, and you’re starting to wonder if God is even listening. Maybe you’ve been waiting for an answer for months or years. Maybe God has already answered, but the answer was no, and you’re struggling to understand why. Keep talking to Him. You can ask again. You can tell Him what you want. You can tell Him that you’re disappointed. You can tell Him that you don’t understand. And then, even when you don’t understand His answer, you can remind yourself of what Jesus told you… your Father is good! We may not always understand the answer, but we can trust the Father. Sometimes the greatest answer to prayer isn’t getting the thing we asked for. Sometimes it is discovering that even when God says no, He is still good, He is still present, and He is still our Father. Rest in that truth today!

Sellers Hickman serves as College & Teaching Pastor at NorthStar Church and loves cheering on his Ole Miss Rebels. He and his wife, Hannah, live in Dallas, Ga. with their two daughters. He also serves as the chaplain for the KSU Men’s Basketball team.

